Unfortunately, the coffee was really disappointing. The espresso lacked flavor, depth, and strength. My Nespresso at home honestly makes better espresso. I was also disappointed to see that they use Torani syrups, which I can easily buy at Target and use myself. For a local coffee shop charging $7.50 for a latte, I would expect house-made syrups or at least higher-quality alternatives that set them apart from what I can make at home. At that price point, the quality of the coffee should reflect what you’re paying for.
On a positive note, the service was great, which is the only reason I’m not giving one star. I just wish the quality of the drinks matched the service and pricing.
Paula Aquiles Alves
-
April 18, 2026
Paid $55 for the most awful food that I literally could have made at home! Caprese toast made on sliced wonder bread with shredded cheese and a few chopped pieces of tomato and avocado toast on whole wheat sliced bread with packaged avocado and a fried egg. I LITERALLY could have made this crap at home and below is pics to prove it. Honestly go somewhere else.
Carmen Rodriguez
-
July 26, 2026
This was our first time visiting, and unfortunately it will also be our last. My husband and I wanted to sit down and enjoy a simple cup of coffee, but the service was disappointing from the moment we walked in. It was a Sunday, not busy at all, only a few people inside. We stood at the counter with no idea how their ordering worked, and the staff didn’t acknowledge us until my husband spoke up.
We ordered two coffees and two pastries. My coffee was cold and extremely dark, and overall the experience did not match the welcoming atmosphere you expect from a local coffee shop. We will not be returning.
Zahir Tuazon
-
June 17, 2026
Cai’s Cafe is a chill spot that gets the job done.
The coffee and drinks are fine - nothing extraordinary, but perfectly serviceable. You can probably find higher-quality options in the surrounding area, but Cai’s makes up for it with a relaxed vibe, friendly people, and a space that works well for hanging out or getting some studying done.
Overall, it’s an average cafe in the most respectable way possible. Not every place needs to change your life. Sometimes it just needs to give you a drink, a seat, and a place to exist for a bit.
Aniket Panchariya
-
November 06, 2023
Been here couple times and both occasions the coffee was not good. Very mild, seems like it didnt had any espresso.
I tried Cafe mocha and Lavender latte. Atmosphere is good, but not good coffee ruins it all. They can do better to improve their coffee!
Our Address
420 Main St, Metuchen, NJ 08840, USA
Claim Listing: Cai’s Cafe
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Unfortunately, the coffee was really disappointing. The espresso lacked flavor, depth, and strength. My Nespresso at home honestly makes better espresso. I was also disappointed to see that they use Torani syrups, which I can easily buy at Target and use myself. For a local coffee shop charging $7.50 for a latte, I would expect house-made syrups or at least higher-quality alternatives that set them apart from what I can make at home. At that price point, the quality of the coffee should reflect what you’re paying for. On a positive note, the service was great, which is the only reason I’m not giving one star. I just wish the quality of the drinks matched the service and pricing.
Paid $55 for the most awful food that I literally could have made at home! Caprese toast made on sliced wonder bread with shredded cheese and a few chopped pieces of tomato and avocado toast on whole wheat sliced bread with packaged avocado and a fried egg. I LITERALLY could have made this crap at home and below is pics to prove it. Honestly go somewhere else.
This was our first time visiting, and unfortunately it will also be our last. My husband and I wanted to sit down and enjoy a simple cup of coffee, but the service was disappointing from the moment we walked in. It was a Sunday, not busy at all, only a few people inside. We stood at the counter with no idea how their ordering worked, and the staff didn’t acknowledge us until my husband spoke up. We ordered two coffees and two pastries. My coffee was cold and extremely dark, and overall the experience did not match the welcoming atmosphere you expect from a local coffee shop. We will not be returning.
Cai’s Cafe is a chill spot that gets the job done. The coffee and drinks are fine - nothing extraordinary, but perfectly serviceable. You can probably find higher-quality options in the surrounding area, but Cai’s makes up for it with a relaxed vibe, friendly people, and a space that works well for hanging out or getting some studying done. Overall, it’s an average cafe in the most respectable way possible. Not every place needs to change your life. Sometimes it just needs to give you a drink, a seat, and a place to exist for a bit.
Been here couple times and both occasions the coffee was not good. Very mild, seems like it didnt had any espresso. I tried Cafe mocha and Lavender latte. Atmosphere is good, but not good coffee ruins it all. They can do better to improve their coffee!